Carroll Homicides

CARROLL – The deaths of a man and woman whose bodies were discovered Wednesday morning in the town of Carroll are being ruled as homicides.

“We’re still processing everything at this time, but I can confirm that these were homicides,” Chautauqua County Sheriff Joe Gerace told The Post-Journal.

“We won’t be able to release any names until an autopsy comes back,” he continued.

Frewsburg firefighters were dispatched around 9:30 a.m. to Wheeler Hill Road for a report of a fire. It’s unclear who reported the blaze, but first responders discovered two bodies in the residence and contacted the Sheriff’s Office.

David Foley, Chautauqua County district attorney, said a warrant was obtained to search the residence. The bodies were removed and taken to Erie County Medical Center in Buffalo by Chautauqua County Coroner John Sixbey for an autopsy. No autopsy has been scheduled at this time.

The scene Wednesday on Wheeler Hill Road was chaotic. By noon, the road was closed to traffic. The county’s mobile command truck and fire investigation team were present, as well as a dozen sheriff’s and local police vehicles.

By 2 p.m., the county’s forensic investigation team arrived.

Relatives who live in the area also were present, but all declined comment.

Earlier Wednesday, police throughout the county were on the lookout for a tan-colored vehicle. Asked of a possible connection between the vehicle and the case, Foley said, “At this time we cannot comment on that.”

Sheriff’s deputies were visible during dismissal at Frewsburg Central School, where afternoon activities were canceled. Superintendent Danielle O’Connor said parents were notified of the Wheeler Hill Road incident through the school’s Global Connect system.

The school is less than five miles from the residence.

“Our goal was to ensure the safety of our students,” O’Connor said. “This was a precautionary measure.”

Students who walk home were required to be picked up by parents; sheriff’s deputies also escorted some students home.

O’Connor said dismissal went smoothly. “I think everything went very well,” she said, later adding, “No child was ever in danger.”